Region Top
Best pizza in New Jersey
Pizzerias in the New Jersey region, ordered by the Best Pizza Index.
#1Star TavernOrange · Bar Pie959.70#2RazzaJersey City · Neapolitan958.80#3Kinchley's TavernRamsey · Thin Crust945.70#4Papa's Tomato PiesRobbinsville · Tomato Pie945.60#5De Lorenzo's Tomato PiesRobbinsville · Tomato Pie942.50#6Pete & Elda's Bar PieNeptune City · Bar Pie942.30#7DeLucia's Brick Oven PizzaRaritan · New Jersey Style942.20#8Benny Tudino'sHoboken · New York Style937.40#9Santillo's Brick Oven PizzaElizabeth · Brick OvenHidden Gem933.60#10Vinnie's MootzLyndhurst · Neapolitan924.90#11Talula'sAsbury Park · NeapolitanHidden Gem923.10#12Lillo's Tomato PiesHainesport · Tomato Pie921.60#13PortaAsbury Park · Neapolitan919.10#14Denino's SouthBrick · New York Style918.60#15Tony Boloney'sAtlantic City · Creative912.70#16Prima PizzaSomers Point · New York StyleHidden Gem912.60#17Carmen's PizzeriaNetcong · New York StyleHidden Gem911.80#18Manco & MancoMarmora · Boardwalk Style910.40#19Ralph's PizzaNutley · Thin Crust909.90#20La PiazzaAllendale · NeapolitanHidden Gem909.40#21Naples PizzaMetuchen · TraditionalHidden Gem907.80#22Nomad PizzaHopewell · Wood FiredHidden Gem907.50#23Johnny PepperoniSea Girt · Wood FiredHidden Gem907.30#24Brother Bruno's PizzaWayne · New York Style905.10#25Casa TuranoSouth Plainfield · Wood FiredHidden Gem904.20#26Sal's PizzeriaLivingston · New York StyleHidden Gem902.70#27Joe's RotisseriaPaterson · Thin CrustHidden Gem901.40#28Velo Wood Fired PizzaWestfield · Wood FiredHidden Gem899.00#29The Galley PizzaAsbury Park · Thin CrustHidden Gem897.90#30Razza Pizza ArtigianaleJersey City · Neapolitan897.70#31Frankie's PizzaPoint Pleasant · TraditionalHidden Gem897.70#32Tino's Artisan PizzaOcean Township · NeapolitanHidden Gem897.10#33Villa PizzaMorristown · New York StyleHidden Gem895.60#34Baci PizzaParamus · New York StyleHidden Gem895.10#35Luigi's Famous PizzaUnion City · New York StyleHidden Gem894.80#36Joey's PizzaKearny · TraditionalHidden Gem894.10#37Rome PizzaEast Brunswick · TraditionalHidden Gem892.80#38Casanova PizzaRutherford · TraditionalHidden Gem890.60#39Artie'sMaplewood · NeapolitanHidden Gem890.20#40The Pizza TerminalVerona · NeapolitanHidden Gem889.80#41Bruno's PizzaClifton · New York StyleHidden Gem888.20#42Bivio PizzaLittle Falls · NeapolitanHidden Gem888.00#43Luca's PizzaSomerville · New York StyleHidden Gem887.90#44Il Forno a LegnaJersey City · Wood FiredHidden Gem887.00#45Jimmy's Tomato PiesPaterson · Tomato PieHidden Gem887.00#46Nunzio's PizzaLong Branch · New York StyleHidden Gem886.90#47Pete & Elda's Bar / Carmen's PizzeriaNeptune City · Thin Crust886.30#48Luna PizzaMedford · NeapolitanHidden Gem886.20#49Romeo's PizzaPiscataway · TraditionalHidden Gem885.00#50Delorenzo's Tomato PiesRobbinsville · Tomato Pie884.00#51Spano's PizzaPoint Pleasant Beach · Boardwalk StyleHidden Gem881.50#52Lodi PizzaLodi · TraditionalHidden Gem881.30#53The Galley Pizza & EateryMiddletown · Thin CrustHidden Gem880.60#54Palermo's PizzaBordentown · TraditionalHidden Gem879.50#55Esposito's PizzaMatawan · TraditionalHidden Gem878.60#56Luigi's Restaurant & PizzaMarlboro · TraditionalHidden Gem877.80#57Primo PizzaNorth Brunswick · New York StyleHidden Gem877.30#58Rocco's PizzaHammonton · TraditionalHidden Gem876.70#59La Strada PizzaRandolph · NeapolitanHidden Gem876.20#60Pizza KnightHackettstown · TraditionalHidden Gem875.20#61Casa PizzaSummit · NeapolitanHidden Gem874.90#62Mia's PizzaHillsborough · New York StyleHidden Gem874.10#63Federici's Family RestaurantFreehold · Thin CrustHidden Gem873.40#64Vincenzo's PizzaRed Bank · TraditionalHidden Gem873.10#65La Famiglia PizzaCranford · TraditionalHidden Gem871.60#66Bread & SaltJersey City · RomanHidden Gem870.60#67Paisano's PizzaHoboken · TraditionalHidden Gem867.30#68Fratelli PizzaCaldwell · NeapolitanHidden Gem866.10#69Mamma Mia PizzaCinnaminson · TraditionalHidden Gem866.00#70Reservoir TavernBoonton · Tavern StyleHidden Gem865.90#71La Gondola PizzaGarfield · TraditionalHidden Gem865.80#72Frank's PizzaEast Rutherford · New York StyleHidden Gem863.20#73Lucca PizzaWest Orange · NeapolitanHidden Gem860.80#74Graziano's PizzaOcean City · Boardwalk StyleHidden Gem859.00#75La FamigliaHackensack · New York StyleHidden Gem858.00#76Cristiano's PizzaFreehold · TraditionalHidden Gem857.70#77Mario & Sons PizzaPhillipsburg · TraditionalHidden Gem857.30#78Marino's PizzeriaDover · TraditionalHidden Gem857.30#79Piazza PizzaWayne · NeapolitanHidden Gem857.10#80Salerno PizzaClark · TraditionalHidden Gem856.70#81Nancy's Towne HouseRahway · Thin CrustHidden Gem855.60#82Antonio's Brick OvenHasbrouck Heights · Brick OvenHidden Gem855.60#83Joe's Brick OvenEnglewood · Brick OvenHidden Gem855.50#84Roma Brick OvenHaddonfield · Brick OvenHidden Gem854.40#85Brooklyn SliceParamus · New York StyleHidden Gem853.80#86Tino's Artisan Pizza Co.Madison · NeapolitanHidden Gem852.90#87Roman GourmetHackensack · RomanHidden Gem852.70#88Luigi's Family PizzaSouth Brunswick · TraditionalHidden Gem852.70#89Brooklyn Brick OvenLivingston · Brick OvenHidden Gem852.50#90La Piazza ItalianaMorris Plains · TraditionalHidden Gem852.50#91Vincenzo's Brick OvenEwing · Brick OvenHidden Gem852.10#92Pizzeria Uno DueCloster · NeapolitanHidden Gem851.40#93Vesuvio Brick OvenRidgefield · Brick OvenHidden Gem851.30#94Gianni's Brick OvenHamilton · Brick OvenHidden Gem850.20#95Luigi's Italian PizzaBerlin · TraditionalHidden Gem850.20#96Salvatore's PizzaEast Brunswick · TraditionalHidden Gem850.00#97Mancini's Coal Oven PizzaMontclair · Coal OvenHidden Gem849.60#98Piazza ItaliaWayne · NeapolitanHidden Gem849.20#99Enzo's Brick OvenWest Milford · Brick OvenHidden Gem846.30#100Brooklyn Brick PizzaUnion · New York StyleHidden Gem845.10#101Mamma Lucia PizzaMiddlesex · TraditionalHidden Gem844.60#102Gio's PizzaEast Brunswick · New York StyleHidden Gem844.40#103Giovanni's Brick OvenMaple Shade · Brick OvenHidden Gem843.90#104Mona Lisa PizzaJackson · TraditionalHidden Gem843.30#105Brick House PizzaEnglewood · Brick OvenHidden Gem843.20#106Capriccio PizzaWest Caldwell · TraditionalHidden Gem842.50#107Luigi's Italian KitchenHillside · TraditionalHidden Gem842.10#108Franco's Brick OvenMorrisville · Brick OvenHidden Gem841.10#109Pizza DenAberdeen · TraditionalHidden Gem841.00#110Bella Vita PizzaWoodbury · NeapolitanHidden Gem839.40#111Lucca's PizzaEast Hanover · TraditionalHidden Gem839.40#112Fratello PizzaEgg Harbor Township · TraditionalHidden Gem838.70#113Toscana PizzaBridgewater · TraditionalHidden Gem838.50#114Pizza TownElmwood Park · New York StyleHidden Gem838.20#115Primo Pizza HouseBergenfield · New York StyleHidden Gem838.10#116Pizza PalaceOcean Township · New York StyleHidden Gem837.60#117La Piazza Ristorante & PizzaAllendale · TraditionalHidden Gem837.10#118Vinnie's Pan PizzaMillburn · Pan PizzaHidden Gem836.60#119Franco's PlaceSummit · TraditionalHidden Gem836.50#120Roma NapoliWest Deptford · TraditionalHidden Gem835.40#121Vesuvio'sPrinceton Junction · NeapolitanHidden Gem834.80#122Cafe Antonio PizzaMatawan · TraditionalHidden Gem834.60#123Nonna Rosa PizzaHillsborough · TraditionalHidden Gem834.20#124Antonio's Italian PizzaMillville · TraditionalHidden Gem833.80#125Trattoria Pizza Co.Sparta · NeapolitanHidden Gem833.50#126Giuseppe's Brick OvenGarwood · Brick OvenHidden Gem833.10#127Casa D'AmiciMorrisville · TraditionalHidden Gem833.10#128Gino's Italian PizzaRahway · TraditionalHidden Gem831.80#129Antonio's Family PizzaWestfield · TraditionalHidden Gem831.40#130Napoli HouseBound Brook · TraditionalHidden Gem830.00#131Roma Family PizzaVoorhees · TraditionalHidden Gem829.90#132Tony's PizzeriaKearny · New York StyleHidden Gem829.80#133Sunray PizzaLittle Falls · TraditionalHidden Gem829.40#134Vesuvio PizzaRunnemede · TraditionalHidden Gem828.60#135Luigi's Pizza PlaceRidgewood · TraditionalHidden Gem824.70#136Roma ExpressParsippany · TraditionalHidden Gem822.70#137Vito's Brick OvenMontville · Brick OvenHidden Gem822.20#138Casa RomaHarrison · TraditionalHidden Gem821.00#139Enzo's Italian PizzaClifton · TraditionalHidden Gem819.10#140Giovanni's Pizza HouseClementon · TraditionalHidden Gem818.10#141Primo Italian PizzaColonia · TraditionalHidden Gem816.60#142Bella Pizza HouseWoodland Park · TraditionalHidden Gem815.80#143Mario's Brick OvenNew Providence · Brick OvenHidden Gem814.40#144Tony's Italian Grill & PizzaRidgefield · New York StyleHidden Gem814.20#145Pizza StopBloomingdale · New York StyleHidden Gem814.20#146Brick Oven Pizza HouseSomerdale · Brick OvenHidden Gem812.20#147Primo Brick OvenCinnaminson · Brick OvenHidden Gem810.90